Mommoisseurs : Recipes | Wine | Camaraderie

Recipes | Wine | Tips & Tricks | Camaraderie | #momlife


Butterfinger Ice Cream

On Monday I got off at 4:00pm, so I got dinner cooked a little early and we all headed to the grocery store afterward to get my weekly shopping done.  It had been a busy weekend and I didn’t have time…or rather, didn’t make time.  Grocery shopping isn’t exactly my favorite thing to do.  But, it was a beautiful day, the kids were in a great mood, and it seemed like a good idea.
It didn’t go too bad, I did hold Clayton most of the time or he was screaming (I never take him to the store with me, in case you didn’t guess), and Callie was begging for this or that.  Shannon decided he wanted to buy an ice cream maker, like the one his mom has in Oklahoma.  She makes the best butterfinger icecream, so instead of cringing at the price, I smiled at the thought of a little unhealthy indulgence later on.

We got home around 7:00, and Shannon started the process of putting the ice cream maker together.  I normally would be busily doing the dishes, or sweeping, or giving the kids a bath, but I couldn’t help feeling their excitement; it was infectious.  I decided the dishes and the baths could wait – I was participating in the fun!

If you’ve ever made homemade ice cream (I had not), you know that it takes much longer than the forty minutes the directions say it does.  So, at 9:30pm, we were still up, way beyond bedtime, waiting (and drooling I’m sure) for the ice cream.  I begged Shannon, who is the direction follower in our family, to just this once, go against the grain and check if it was done.  It was humming loudly and straining to churn; I was sure this was a sign it was done.  But, Shannon being the level-headed person of our team…waited it out and sure enough…it clicked off and we finally got to enjoy some of the yummiest Butterfinger ice cream ever.

Even though we were up way past bedtime with a sugar-high, and the ice cream took forever, and I went to bed with dishes in the sink…and the kids with no bath, it was one of the best evenings of the year so far.  All we did was make ice cream!  While we were out the $50 for the maker, next time all we’ll have to pay for is the ingredients.  We may hear it all the time, but it doesn’t matter…I’m still amazed at how the simple things, the small things are what you remember.

I’ve included Janet’s (Shannon’s mom) super recipe below:

You’ll Need:
1 Eagle Brand Evaporated Milk
3/4 Cup Sugar
1 tsp Vanilla
dash of sea salt
2 Eggs
5 Butterfinger Bars, crushed
1/2 a gallon of 2% milk
Rock salt/icecream salt

mix together the evaporated milk, sugar, vanilla,  sea salt, eggs, and butterfingers, and 2 cups of the milk in your blender, and blend well.  Put in the ice cream tin, fill the remaining tin up to fill line with the remainder of the milk.  Add the crushed butterfingers.  Surround the outside of the tin with ice and rock salt per the ice cream makers instructions, and viola, in (much longer than forty minutes, I assure you) you’ll have homemade delight and some enjoyable memories that will last. ~ Trina

Print Friendly

Related Posts

You Might Also Like

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Speer Family Chili

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Coconut Curried Pumpkin Soup

The terrible twos begin…

Easy Berry Cobbler

Flourless Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

Alfredo with Grilled Chicken

How did I forget that potty training sucks?

Polynesian Pork Chops

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Burritos Delicioso

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Desserts – Leah’s Favorite Cookies

Million Dollar Spaghetti

Skinny Meatloaf Cupcakes with Mashed Potato Frosting

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Rocky Mountain Enchiladas & Chili Rellenos

Carole’s Pizza

Chicken Korma

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Broccoli & Cheese Casserole

Go, Mommy, Go! Be your own child-rearing cheerleader!

Delectable Macaroni & Cheese

Souflaki Pita Sandwiches

Pumpkin Cupcakes

Shrimp Etouffee

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Chicken with Lemon-Caper Sauce

Avocado Cream Cheese Wontons With Cilantro Lime Dipping Sauce

A Florida Speer Family Christmas

Cheese & Jalapeño Baked Stuffed Chicken

Skinny Chicken Enchiladas

Caramelized Onion and Goat Cheese Crostini

Columbian Steak with Onions & Tomatoes

​Creole Jambalaya

Cauliflower Crust Pizza

Holiday Recipe Spectacular ~Crock Pot Apple Butter: An Awesome Gift In a Jar! 12/16/11

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Dessert – Angel Cherry Pie

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Soup – Sweet Potato Jalapeno Soup

Today’s forecast: Scattered mom likely

Shepherd’s Pot Pie

Babysitting woes & Eric Church

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Roasted Tomato Basil Soup

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Parmesan-Dijon Chicken

The Precious Age of 6

Samuel L. Jackson’s narration of Adam Mansbach’s “Go the F*ck to Sleep”

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Appetizer – Honey Brie Spread

Kiddos & plane rides = Disaster

Competitive mommies: What are you preparing for the preschool Thanksgiving feast?

Blackberry Bread

Crockpot Beef Tips

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Appetizer – Bronco Cheese Ball

Garlic Chicken Lasagna

Philly Cheeseburger Skillet Dinner

A letter to my son on his fourth birthday

Healthy & Hearty Pizza

Grilled Tilapia with Mango Salsa

Moms raising boys and their endless energy

The evolution of my sons love for being in the water

Spicy Oven-Roasted Chickpeas

5 groovy ways to keep your kids entertained during a hurricane

What vacation is like after you have your first baby

Dallas-Style Sloppy Joes

Beef Stew on Toast

Grilled Steak Fajitas with Flank Steak

Chicken Marsala with Pancetta and Cream

Slow-Cooker Kid-Friendly Chili

Easy Chicken Parmesan Bake

Salmon Burgers

Cauliflower Crust Pizza

Chicken Parmesan w/Whole Wheat Pasta

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Slow Cooker Ham and Bean New Year’s Meal

Pineapple Bacon Burgers

Crescent Burgers

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Carolina Barbecued Pork

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement~Healthy Beef Stroganoff

Optimistic? Or just plain ol’ dumb parenting?

Spicy Cuban Mojo Chicken with Mango-Avocado Salsa

Cardinal Rule #1: Thou shalt not sleep in thy mother’s bed

Why you should take responsiblity for your child’s success in school

Chicken Souvlaki

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement~ Southwest Chicken Soup

What is it with bad boys anyway?

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement~ Spinach Strawberry Salad

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Homemade Chicken & Veggie Soup

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement~Chicken breasts with Avocado, Tomato, and Cucumber Salsa

Lemon Chicken Stir-Fry

Enjoying today, cherishing yesterday and looking forward to tomorrow

Philly Cheese Steak Sloppy Joes

Starbucks anyone?

Enjoying the beautiful things in life

Double Crunch Honey Garlic Pork Chops

Chicken & Mushrooms in Garlic White Wine Sauce

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Cilantro Lime Chicken

Flash Pan Beef Fajitas

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Chicken Chimichangas w/Guacamole

Ground Turkey Pasta Bake

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Desserts – Pecan Pie Tarts

New Ways to Prepare Healthy Snacks – Guest Post by Barry Zagreb

Taco Pizza

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement~ Healthy Chicken Parmesan

A mommy’s school bus jitters

Chicken Curry Soup with Coconut and Lime

Eggplant Lasagna

Ginger-Scallion Salmon

Buffalo Chicken Soup

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Sante Fe Casserole Bake

Holiday Recipe Spectacular~Southern Green Bean Casserole

Guest Post: Road tripping with your kids without the strife

Holiday Recipe Spectacular ~ A Holiday Brunch: Sourdough Strata

Cranberry Margarita

Then there was Kindergarten…

Reason #33: How Do I Explain Death to My Baby?

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Side Dishes – Poppy Seed Green Beans

Pumpkin Bread

Desperate times call for desperate measures

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Pumpkin Spice Latte Cheesecake

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Buffalo Chicken Rolls.

Best Birthday Cake Ever!

The New Age of Dinosaurs

Garlic Pork

Pumpkin Pie Bars

Things We are Thankful For This Thanksgiving

And…now he’s 3

Spicy Stuffed Mushrooms

How to Roast Perfect Pumpkin Seeds

The fun language of a two-year-old

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Appetizer – Wasabi-Ginger Crusted Scallops

15 Fun ideas for kid lunches

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Kathy’s Classic Roman Pasta with Lemon Chicken

Why do boys have tails?

Honey Whole Wheat Bread

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Dessert – Choco-Cherries

Panang Curry with Chicken

Cheese Stuffed Beef Rolls

While they dream

A party fit for a 2-year-old

Cheesy Beef & Rice Bake

Tomato & Pasta al Forno

Creating your own hybrid family

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Breakfast – Haitian French Toast

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Healthy & Hearty Pasta

Slow Cooker Chicken Marsala

Preschool Graduation

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Chili-Pasta Skillet

Turkey & Black Bean Enchiladas

The end to an epic summer

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement- Grandma’s Chicken Pot Pie

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Ring

Frozen Peppermint Cheesecake

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Dessert – Apple Dumplings

Honey Cinnamon Roasted Sweet Potatoes

Happy 2nd birthday to my baby boy!

Pasta Pie

Roasted Zucchini, Corn and Tomatoes

Shrimp & Cauliflower Soup

You know you’re a mommy of young boys when…

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~Pasta with Prosciutto-Sage Cream Sauce

Chicken Avocado Lime Soup

Slow Cooker Tuscan Beef Stew

Chicken Tortilla Soup

The Heavy: A Mother, a Daughter, A Diet – A Mother Goes to Extremes

Southwestern Chopped Salad with Cilantro Dressing

The Bloomin’ Zucchini & Sweet Onion Dip

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Swiss Steak

Oh My Gosh…you’re 3!

Chicken Pomodoro

Homemade Beef Stew with Rice

Whole Wheat Chocolate Chip Cookies

Quick skillet steak with onions & mushrooms

Keeping Up with the Cleavers…or Not So Much

Mini Ham and Swiss Sandwiches with Poppy Seed Glaze

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Chicken Cacciatore Pasta

Cheesy Chicken & Rice Casserole

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Classic 70s 7-Layer Dip

Squashing this all-American dream

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Side Dish – Connecticut Meat Stuffing

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Sour Cream Enchiladas

‘Tis The Season – The Decision on Giving

Holiday Recipe Spectacular -Sugar Cookie & Frosting Recipe

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Desserts – Brownie Christmas Trees

Sesame Chicken

Buffalo Turkey Burgers with Blue Cheese Slaw

Mommy, that dream catcher you gave me doesn’t work!

Football Dorito Nachos

After the massacre: What can you be sure of…

Why moms shouldn’t get sick

Different kids, different ages, different stages…It’s all good!

Recipe: Sweet Potato Turkey Shepherds Pie

Holiday Recipe Spectacular ~ Peppermint Bark

Stir Fry in a Tortilla

Chunky Beef Stew

Man publicly shames 3-Year-old daughter

Homeade Chicken Noodle Soup

Bedtime battles continued

Pumpkin Doughnut Muffins

Guest Bloggers, Causes We Believe In, Recipes, Mommy Advice and Humor… and Wine in 2012

Salmon with Lemon and Dill

A mommy’s school bus jitters

Slow Cooker Cilantro Lime Chicken Tacos

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Carrabba’s Chicken Bryan

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Cookies – Colorful Swirl Christmas Sugar Cookies

Baked Sweet & Sour Chicken with Fried Rice

Very Veggie Skillet Casserole

Pork Tenderloin with Pan Sauce

McCormick® Slow Cooker BBQ Pork Sandwiches

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Pumpkin Tiramisu

I’m not lovin’ it!

Housekeepers and Such

Going From Firm to Sweet in a Millisecond – The Emotional Switches in Motherhood

Lemon Oregano Pork Tenderloin with Lemon Jus

Grilled Flank Steak with Tomatoes, Red Onion & Basalmic

Who gets sick on vacation, anyway?

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Side Dish – Glazed Sweet Potatoes

Their happiness in our heart

Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti Squash

Toddlers Eating Habits – Just Enough To Keep A Baby Bird Alive?

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Appetizer – Red Pepper Hummus

Italian Stuffed Chicken

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Pecan Pie

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Naughty Christmas Coal

Best Sugar Cookie & Hard Cookie Frosting Recipe for Decorating

Steak Diane

What moms want from a President

Vegetable Skillet Casserole

Whole Wheat Beef & Bean Burritos

Deep Dish Chicken Pot Pie

Orange Chicken Stir Fry

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Apple Cinnamon Pork Roast

Chicken Fajitas

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~Chicken Paella

Red Pepper Hummus

Pepper Steak & Rice

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Christmas Swirl Chocolate Bars 12/16/11

Slow Cooker Ham, Green Beans & Potatoes

Light Cajun Chicken Pasta

Mother’s Day around the world

Why are some children’s movies just so sad?

A Life of Purpose – Inspiring Guest Post from Cancer Survivor and Real Mom, Heather Von St. James

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Honey-Pecan Chicken Breasts

Reuben Sandwiches

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Healthy Sweet Potato Bake

Everyday Skillet Lasagna

Creamy Beef & Sweet Potato Casserole

Buttery Garlic Pull-Apart Bread

Happy Halloween!!

Lemon Butter Salmon Recipe

Why I left preschool crying…

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Appetizer – Thai Chicken Wonton Cups

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Dessert – Butter Horns

Bliss to be savored

Rooster: Our Newest Family Member

Skinny Broccoli and Beef

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Desserts – Praline Fudge

Holiday Recipe Spectacular: Pumpkin Spice Muffins

Buffalo Chicken Lasagna

Beef & Bean Taco Casserole

Is baby-making making you crazy?

Another Easter…A New Spring

Pasta pizza

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement ~ Cheesy Enchilada Casserole

Cooking with kids

Greek Turkey Burgers

Mango Pulled Pork Sandwiches

5 groovy ways to keep your kids entertained while being hunkered down during a hurricane

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Cinnamon Apple Pork Chops

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Beverages – Orange Almond Sparkle

Blueberry Lemon Glazed Doughnut Muffins

Merry Christmas Everyone!!

Curried Chicken Salad Sandwiches

Has your doc ever tried to smooch you?

Shrimp Salad

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Penne Pasta Bake

Kahlua Grilled Shrimp Pasta

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Appetizer – Easy Veggie Dip

The Anti-Chicken Fingers Movement – Creamy Meat & Potato Casserole

Holiday Recipe Spectacular – Desserts – Italian Rainbow Cookies

Southwest Style Chicken Burgers

Holy competition, Batman!

Bethenny Frankel’s Ultra-Healthy Mexican Chili

Queso Chicken

Delivering grace: Teaching lessons that will last a lifetime

Leave a Reply